What Independents?
avatar

But He’s the Only ELECTABLE One! | Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler

Yeah, we highlighted that particular bit since it seems rather important, now that we’ve heard time and time again that the base just has to shut up and eat the shit sandwich because Mittens the Fair Haired RINO of Taxachusetts is all about the Independents!!!11!1!1!

You know, “it doesn’t really matter what the worthless, dependable slaves on the plantation think, we have to get the independents.” How’s that working out for you, Mr. Electable? Because it seems to us that, even if you assume for the sake of discussion that that’s true, dropping 20 points because you’ve shown yourself to be a carbon copy of he inexcusably vile leftists among said independents isn’t exactly, how can we put it?, WINNING!

One of the things all the Gentry GOP moderate losers miss entirely is that the so-called independent vote isn’t monolithic. It has preferences and tendencies it follows as well. And guess what?

Ezra Klein – Research desk responds: How partisan are ‘independent’ voters?

Research on this question suggests that there are, in fact, swing voters, but that they are far fewer than they’re made out to be. The defining work on this subject is Bruce Keith et. al.’s “The Myth of the Independent Voter,” published in 1992, which broke down independent voters into three categories: independents who lean Democratic, independents who lean Republican, and pure independents. The “leaners” voted for Republican and Democratic candidates with about the same frequency that self-identified Republicans and Democrats did. Only pure independents were unpredictable, and amounted to just under 10 percent of the electorate. These were the true swing voters, but there were not that many of them.

The book’s findings have held up since its publication. In the 2008 election, “pure independents” made up only 7 percent of the electorate, and leaners still voted overwhelmingly for the candidates of the party they identified as leaning toward. This behavior holds up even between elections, in things like presidential approval polls. George Washington University’s John Sides analyzed ABC/Washington Post presidential approval polls from 2009 and broke them down based on whether respondents were pure independents, leaners or partisans:

obama approval and pid-thumb.png

Democratic leaners are barely distinguishable from Democrats, Republican leaners are barely distinguishable from Republicans, and pure independents — representing all of 7 percent of the electorate — were the only group to go from approving to disapproving of Obama.

So the Crap Sandwich Republicans want to toss conservatism down the rathole in order to scrabble for some portion of seven percent of the vote?

Figures. They aren’t just the stupid party. They’re the suicidal party.

About Bill Quick

I am a small-l libertarian with conservative leanings on most issues, except on many traditionally conservative social issues, where my stance would be regarded as hopelessly liberal by most social conservatives. My primary concern is to increase individual liberty as much as possible in the face of statist efforts to restrict it from both the right and the left. If I had to sum up my beliefs as concisely as possible, I would say, "Stay out of my wallet and my bedroom," "your liberty stops at my nose," and "don't tread on me." I will believe that things are taking a turn for the better in America when married gays are able to, and do, maintain large arsenals of automatic weapons, and tax collectors are, and do, not.
Gentry GOP, Shit Sandwich, Stupid PartyPermalink

0 Responses to What Independents?

  1. Pingback: The alternative » Cold Fury

  2. Lorenzo says:

    When you look at the expansion of the independents, you also see a drop in Dem/GOP registration. I suspect these people just got tired of the mailbox stuffing, requests for donations and phone calls they were getting. The Onion may have discovered a truism when they reported that the leading candidate in a New York City telephone poll was “Get the hell off my phone!”

    To get away from the attack ads on TV that turned off South Carolina voters and flummoxed Florida voters, people are contributing to the expansion of cable. I got expanded cable so I could find refuge in a re-run of Bob Vila installing a toilet, and the ads haven’t even started in Cali yet.

return to main page (at this post)

Show Comments (2)